DRIP VS PIVOT

DRIP VS PIVOT

DRIP VS PIVOT

Product catalog summary
Introduction
This document compares two leading irrigation technologies: drip and center pivot systems. It highlights the advantages and disadvantages of each, focusing on financial, operational, and environmental aspects.

Financial Analysis
Center pivots are generally more cost-effective than drip systems. Initial investment costs for pivots range from $800 to $1,200 per hectare, whereas drip systems can be 20% to 100% more expensive. Pivots also have a longer lifespan (25+ years) compared to drip systems (10-15 years) and retain 50% of their resale value after 15 years.

Operational Efficiency
Center pivots require less labor and maintenance than drip systems. Drip systems demand constant monitoring and maintenance, including flushing filters and lines. In contrast, pivots can be managed by fewer personnel using computerized controls.

Water and Crop Management
Pivots are versatile and can handle wastewater without advanced filtration, unlike drip systems which require specific tapes and emitters. Pivots also facilitate easier crop rotation and do not suffer from salt build-up issues associated with drip systems.

Environmental Impact
Drip systems have a higher environmental impact due to the disposal of drip tape, which lasts about 5 years. In contrast, Valley pivot equipment is made from 100% recyclable steel.

Maintenance and Design
Drip systems have higher annual maintenance costs (7-10% of initial investment) compared to pivots (1-2%). The design and installation of drip systems are complex, whereas pivot systems are simpler and standardized.

Conclusion
Overall, center pivots offer significant advantages over drip systems in terms of cost, durability, labor efficiency, and environmental impact. They are recommended for large-scale commercial agriculture.
See more

Catalog excerpts

DRIP VS PIVOT-1

Comparing Drip and Pivots RELIABLE I DURABLE I PRECISE I ADVANCED I RESPONSIVE

 Open the catalog to page 1
DRIP VS PIVOT-2

You Can't Afford Not to Use Pivot Irrigation. In recent years, two effective and efficient irrigation methods have emerged as the leading technologies — drip and center pivots. People now associate distinct advantages and disadvantages with each. Some of these are true. Some are myths. So how do you make a decision between the two? You compare the facts. There are at least five important areas where you should pay special attention: • annual return on investment • initial investment costs • labor costs • water efficiency • crop versatility After fully analyzing these issues, you’ll find that...

 Open the catalog to page 2
DRIP VS PIVOT-3

Center Pivots Cost Less, Last Longer, and Retain Their Value. $124 When it comes to initial investment costs, center pivots are much less expensive than their drip irrigation counterparts. $66,525 $63,786 Center pivot irrigation equipment typically costs between $800 and $1,200 per hectare. Drip systems cost between 20% to 100% more. Pivots also last twice as long — 25-plus years for center pivots compared to a typical 10-15 years for drip systems. Drip Net Returns Pivot $15,500 $9,357 75% - 98% And even after 15 years, Valley pivots retain 50% of their value for resale. Drip systems? After removing...

 Open the catalog to page 3
DRIP VS PIVOT-4

Comparing Drip and Pivots? There Is No Comparison. Initial Cost Filter Maintenance • Pivots typically cost between $800 and $1,200 per hectare. • You must constantly monitor drip system filters, then flush or change them when necessary to prevent system failure. • Drip systems cost 20% to 100% more than pivots. Maintenance Cost • Typically filtering is not required when using a pivot or linear. • The normal, annual cost to maintain a drip system is about 7-10% of the initial investment. Life Span • On a center pivot used 2,000 hours per year, the annual maintenance cost is about 1-2% of the original...

 Open the catalog to page 4

All Valley Irrigation catalogs and technical brochures

  1. CORNERS

    4  Pages

  2. LINEARS

    12  Pages

  3. STRUCTURES

    4  Pages

  4. DRIVE TRAIN

    12  Pages

  5. CABLEGUARD™

    4  Pages

  6. SUGAR CANE

    4  Pages

  7. RICE MYTHS

    8  Pages

*Prices are pre-tax. They exclude delivery charges and customs duties and do not include additional charges for installation or activation options. Prices are indicative only and may vary by country, with changes to the cost of raw materials and exchange rates.